Absolutely incredible! The cacio e pepe was perfectly creamy — not a clump in sight. Our server Lucia made us feel like regulars on our first visit. The limoncello on the house at the end was such a lovely touch. We're already planning our next visit for the Sunday tasting menu. Best Italian in the city, hands down.

Great food — the burrata starter and the lamb ragu tagliatelle were both outstanding. Gave 4 stars instead of 5 only because the noise level makes conversation tough on weekends. Would recommend coming on a weeknight for a better experience. Tiramisu is a must-order.

Mario himself stopped by our table twice! The seafood linguine had the most perfectly cooked clams I've ever tasted and the broth was so good I asked for bread to soak it up. Cozy, romantic atmosphere — perfect for date night. My girlfriend said it's the best restaurant she's been to in New York. We'll be back monthly.

Celebrated my 30th birthday here and the team went above and beyond. They brought out a candle in the panna cotta without being asked (my partner must have mentioned it when booking). The private corner booth was perfectly arranged. Honestly made my birthday special. The mushroom risotto is life-changing — order it.

Solid neighborhood spot. I've been three times now — consistency is good which is rare. The pasta is always al dente, the service is friendly, and the wine list is reasonably priced for the area. Docking one star only because reservations book out 3+ weeks which makes spontaneous visits tough. Worth planning ahead for though.

The chef's tasting menu was a full 2-hour journey and every course was a surprise. Highlights: the truffle arancini amuse-bouche, the 24-hour short rib, and the chocolate-hazelnut semifreddo. The sommelier's wine pairings were spot on without being pretentious. This is special-occasion dining done right. Worth every penny.